dhcpcd-discuss

Re: ISP does not reply to DHCP_DISCOVER

Duncan Webb

Wed Feb 17 20:07:45 2010

On 16/02/2010 12:15, Roy Marples wrote:
On 16/02/2010 11:04, Duncan Webb wrote:
Other than the Maximum DHCP Message Size I don't see anything that is
significant. The Vendor class identifier was copied from the ipcop box
that I'm currently using as a firewall.

OK

I'm seeing other DHCP messages in the tcpdump trace, so I reckon that
the server is seeing my messages.

If it's seeing them, then it should be sending replies back. Can you see
these via tcpdump? Can you email me a full tcpdump for analysis in
wireshark? Can you run dhcpcd with debugging enabled (add the word debug
on its own line in /etc/dhcpcd.conf) and see if dhcpcd is rejecting it
for any reason?

Looks like I have found the problem and it seems to be hardware related.

I was using a POE (power-over-ethernet) connector to supply power to the ALIX board. Connecting the cable directly from the modem into the red connector and bingo the dhcpcd daemon comes alive and provides an IP address.

In case someone want to know what POE is, it provides power to the device through the Ethernet cable instead of connecting power directly into the case. My guess is that some how the power was disrupting the Ethernet packets.

Thanks,
Duncan

References:
ISP does not reply to DHCP_DISCOVERDuncan Webb
Re: ISP does not reply to DHCP_DISCOVERDuncan Webb
Re: ISP does not reply to DHCP_DISCOVERRoy Marples
Archive administrator: postmaster@marples.name